Male employees reluctant to engage with gender equality initiatives

Image: Shutterstock
Nov 13 2024 by Management-Issues Print This Article

A new study conducted among male employees in the European region of a leading multinational manufacturing company reveals a stark disengagement with gender equality issues in the workplace.

The research, led by Hult International Business School, found that while the empowerment of women remains essential, involving men as active allies is crucial for driving real change toward gender equity.

However, despite efforts to engage men in gender equity discussions, only one in 10 (10%) of the 2,500 male employees invited to participate in the study responded. This highlights a significant lack of involvement from men on this issue.

One key finding of the study was that personal experience leads to engagement. Men who have daughters or have personally known women who faced discrimination were more likely to engage in gender equality discussions. In fact, 42% of the respondents had daughters, and many cited this as a key motivator for their awareness of gender equity issues.

The survey also exposed a gap in awareness, with half of the respondents avoiding gender equity-related questions altogether, signalling reluctance to engage. Overall, 42% did not answer questions about company policies on gender equality, and of those who did, only 36% were aware of the company’s existing policies.

Among those who participated, 30% were aware of women facing discrimination, 27% knew of unfair treatment, 21% knew of women who had been underpaid, and 16% knew women who had been harassed. This suggests that men without exposure to these conversations or personal experiences with discrimination may be less likely to engage.

Despite the low participation, many respondents expressed a willingness to support gender equity initiatives but reported fears of saying the wrong thing, discomfort with challenging traditional gender roles, and a lack of understanding. This highlights the need for more effective training and guidance to help men feel equipped to engage in these important conversations.

A third (32%) of respondents felt that gender equity is framed as a "women's issue," with men often seen as the problem. However, there was significant interest in supporting these initiatives, with men emphasising the importance of equal pay, an inclusive culture, and leadership commitment to gender equity.

"This study underscores the complexities of achieving gender equity, especially in male-dominated environments,” said Dr Debbie Bayntun-Lees, Professor of Organisational Development and Leadership at Hult International Business School, who led the study. “While there is growing awareness and commitment to gender equity, significant gaps persist in engagement, understanding, and support from male employees.”

"Men's participation in fostering gender-equitable workplaces is crucial,” she added. “It promotes accountability, amplifies marginalized voices, and strengthens organizational cohesion. To achieve true equity, cultural shifts are needed within companies, and men - especially in leadership - must play a vital role. This study reinforces the importance of equipping men with the knowledge and confidence to become effective allies in the workplace. Gender equity is not just a women’s issue; it requires collective action and commitment from everyone."