Skip to main content

Self-help skepticism

Sep 11 2009 by Jurgen Wolff
Print This Article

I've always been skeptical of the self-help advice to use affirmations such as, "I am thin," if you are overweight, or "I make a million a year," when you're barely able to cover your rent. So I was glad to see that a study published in the journal Psychological Science, confirms this.

The author of the report said repeating positive statements worked only if it reinforced what the person already genuinely believed to be true. If the person knew it wasn't true, the counter-argument ("Actually, I'm fat," or "A million? I'm broke!") overwhelms the positive.

So what to do? One method that I think does work is to figure out what behaviour would move you in the direction of your desired outcome, then visualize yourself doing it before you do it for real.

For instance, if you want to lose weight and have been invited to a friend's place for dinner, picture yourself saying "no, thank you" to the dessert. It works even better if you imagine it twice: first as though you're watching yourself on a movie screen, then through your own eyes.

Related Categories

Latest book reviews

MORE BOOK REVIEWS

Super Adaptability: How to Transcend in an Age of Overwhelm

Super Adaptability: How to Transcend in an Age of Overwhelm

Max McKeown

Max Mckeown's heavyweight new book draws from neuroscience, psychology and cultural evolution to develop a practical framework for human adaptability.

Hone - How Purposeful Leaders Defy Drift

Hone - How Purposeful Leaders Defy Drift

Geoff Tuff and Steven Goldbach

In a business landscape obsessed with transformation and disruption, Hone offers a refreshingly counterintuitive approach to today's organisational challenges.

The Confidence Myth

The Confidence Myth

Ginka Toegel

How can women leaders break free from gendered perceptions? Professor Ginka Toegel’s new book challenges the narrative that female leaders lack confidence or that women need to "fix" themselves, arguing for a fundamental shift in how organisations recognise and reward competence.