Skip to main content
Illustrative article header image
Image: Shutterstock

Between a rock and a hard place

Nov 06 2007 by Charles Helliwell
Print This Article

Dear Management-Issues...

I am a teacher for one of the best counties in my area. I love the fact that teachers have the summer off and are able to make extra income if they so desire. Teaching is rewarding, I love working with my students, my department is superb and caring.

However, the salary that I'm being paid as a teacher is not enough to take care of my family's finances. I hate living from paycheck to paycheck. I'm in the dilemma of having to make a decision to change careers for financial stability or keep my peace of mind and continue to live paycheck to paycheck.

My husband is a blue collar worker and together it still not enough. I have a better chance of getting a new position before he does. My degree is in business, and there are plenty of opportunities for business graduates.

But we will be first-time parents in December and if I transfer out of teaching now, I'll miss the time I would like to spend with my newborn during the summer months. What great business positions are out there now, where they still cater for people with families?

Susan, Meryland

Charles Helliwell's Answer:

Well Susan, you appear to be caught between a rock and a hard place. It would be only too simple for me to advise you to put your family first and go with your passion for teaching; however, that's not going to solve the increasing financial dilemma you currently face and it's not going to get any easier with a new addition to your family either.

So, let's apply your dilemma to one of the best known quotations of Sherlock Holmes; namely, "when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."

You love teaching.

You love your job; your students and your department.

Your paycheck is currently insufficient for your family's finances.

You could change career and go into business.

Your husband doesn't have the flexibility you do.

So, what's impossible is to carry on what you're currently doing and earn sufficient for your family's needs.

What might be possible is to go into business and earn more, but sacrifice spending the time you say you want with your new baby. So this too is now impossible.

Your 'knowns' are that you love what you do and where you currently do it, so this now becomes the truth, with the improbable being how you're going to persuade them to pay you more.

But because this is now so important to you and your family, that's precisely what you're going to do. That also happens to be the one option you haven't even considered, assuming it to be either impossible or improbable.

So, talk to your employers. Explain to them your dilemma. Show them how passionate you feel about the job and the environment, and ask them what else you might be able to do for them to top-up your paycheck. You never know; your future might just be staring you in the face, but you just can't see it.

Latest book reviews

MORE BOOK REVIEWS

Hone - How Purposeful Leaders Defy Drift

Hone - How Purposeful Leaders Defy Drift

Geoff Tuff and Steven Goldbach

In a business landscape obsessed with transformation and disruption, Hone offers a refreshingly counterintuitive approach to today's organisational challenges.

Super Adaptability: How to Transcend in an Age of Overwhelm

Super Adaptability: How to Transcend in an Age of Overwhelm

Max McKeown

Max Mckeown's heavyweight new book draws from neuroscience, psychology and cultural evolution to develop a practical framework for human adaptability. It might also help you move from paralysis into abundance

Lead Like Julius Caesar

Lead Like Julius Caesar

Paul Vanderbroeck

What can Julius Caesar's imperfect story - his spectacular failures as well as his success - tell us about contemporary leadership challenges?